10 Great Places to Buy a Delicious Pie in Saratoga County NY This Holiday Season
Nothing beats the taste of a pie during the holiday season, but if you're not a baker, no worries! There are plenty of bake shops where you can order a delicious homemade pie in Saratoga County, NY. From apple crumb to pumpkin, triple berry and beyond, treat your family to a pie this year from one of these 10 local businesses.
King Brothers Dairy: Find Homemade Ice Cream Pies, Cakes, and Local Favorites
Located in Schuylerville, King Brothers Dairy is known for its fresh milk and homemade ice cream, but the farm store also doubles as a local dessert destination. Visitors can pick up ice cream pies, cakes, cupcakes, and other sweet treats made right on site.
Alongside their own creations, King Brothers Dairy carries Smith’s Orchard pies and New Skete cheesecakes, giving shoppers a taste of two other beloved regional bakeries. Seasonal favorites and limited-time desserts rotate throughout the year, with special pre-orders available for the major holidays like Thanksgiving.
Outside of the holiday rush, desserts are sold on a first-come, first-served basis, so it’s worth stopping in early to see what’s available!
Smith’s Orchard Bake Shop: Choose From Over 20 Types of Fruit Pie
Fresh baked pies are always on the menu at Smith’s Orchard Bake Shop in Ballston Spa; in fact, they’ve been selling them ever since the shop opened back in 1999. All of their fruit pies are made with a regular or crumb crust, and pre-orders are available before the major holidays (Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter).
One of the main reasons people continue to return to Smith’s Orchard is because of the wide variety of flavors to choose from, such as apple, apple blueberry, blackberry, cherry, pecan, raspberry peach, strawberry rhubarb…the list goes on and on.
As one customer shared, “Very good pies, tarts, cakes and so much more! If you're in the area stop in, you definitely won't be disappointed! For holiday desserts, place your order well in advance—they get very busy!”
Be sure to check their website for order deadlines and holiday pre-order forms. If you miss the deadline, you may still be able to purchase a pie from their store or at a local shop that carries their pies like King Brothers.
Saratoga Apple: Stock Up on Cider, Pies, and More
Located in Schuylerville, Saratoga Apple isn't just a top spot for apples (although they do sell over 20 types from August - October). They also operate a farm market and bakery that's open year round and features products like fresh apple cider, hard cider, apple cider doughnuts, and apple pies made using their famous top-secret recipe.
Saratoga Apple often has seasonal pies too, such as peach-raspberry and plum-ginger. You can call to custom order a pie or see what's available in store.
The Bread Basket Bakery: Baking a Difference in Saratoga Springs
Did you know The Bread Basket Bakery is part of the Business for Good family of companies? That means every pie you purchase helps support efforts to fight food insecurity across the Capital Region.
When you pick up a holiday dessert from The Bread Basket, you’re not just sharing something delicious with family, you’re also giving back to the community.
One happy customer said, “We ordered two pies for Thanksgiving this year. Hands down the best pumpkin pie and coconut cream pie I have ever eaten. Incredible!”
Their holiday menu features favorites like apple crumb, cherry, and of course pumpkin pie, along with other seasonal treats. Quantities are limited, so be sure to place your order soon.
Putnam Market: Pick Up One of the Shop’s Tempting Seasonal Pies
For some of the best pies in downtown Saratoga Springs, you can't go wrong with the Putnam Market, which offers something for everyone around the holidays.
You can shop for ingredients to make the perfect holiday meal, find a gift basket for friends or family, or purchase one of their exceptional pies.
Putnam Market's pie crusts are made from scratch, and the filling varies by the season (pro tip: the Mixed Berry Pie with a crumb topping is their best seller).
Give them a call today and ask about which flavors are currently available.
Iron Roost: From Breakfast to the Baked Goods, Everything Is Scratch-Made
Popularly known throughout the Saratoga Springs area for offering some of the most flavorful breakfast and lunch waffles, Iron Roost’s other claim to fame is their scratch-made baked goods and desserts.
Their goal is to use the finest and freshest ingredients to create food that will warm your heart, including homemade apple (double crust), apple crumb, and pumpkin pies, which are available freshly baked or frozen.
Iron Roost’s cafe/bakery is located in downtown Ballston Spa, and in addition to pies, they sell cheesecakes, breads, tarts, cakes, and other treats. You can view the full selection of baked goods on the Bakery section of their website.
Lakeside Farms: Your One-Stop Shop for Both Holiday Desserts & Gifts
Need to get a Thanksgiving pie in Saratoga County? During the holiday season, Lakeside Farms in Ballston Lake welcomes everyone to their country store, restaurant, and gift shoppe.
This family owned business is renowned for offering delicious homemade pies, and according to one customer, “The bakery is amazing and has a slew of pie choices available every day as well as many other baked goods.”
We suggest stopping for a meal, picking up a pie for the holidays, and browsing their unique selection of holiday gift items, such as mugs, bowls, hats, scarves, seasonal decor, and more.
The Sweetish Chef: Discover Quality Baked Goods for All Special Diets
With a name like The Sweetish Chef, you know that you can expect a wide range of sweet treats and baked goods on the menu. However, what makes them truly stand out is their commitment to making food that everyone can enjoy, whether it’s grain/gluten free, sugar free, or low carb treats.
Browse their selection of regular menu items and holiday baked goods; the pumpkin pie and Dutch “Apple” Pie are favorites around Thanksgiving.
Mourningkill Farm and Bake Shop: A Small Family Farm With Big Flavors
For nearly five decades, Mourningkill Farm and Bake Shop in Ballston Spa has been delighting customers with fresh, homemade pies baked from time-tested family recipes. Each pie features a light, flaky crust and flavorful fillings made with high-quality local ingredients, often sourced from the family’s own farm.
All pies and breads are made fresh to order, so advance ordering is required. The bake shop will begin taking Thanksgiving pie orders by phone only starting Saturday, November 1. Email orders cannot be accepted at this time.
J&S Watkins Desserts: Find Gourmet Desserts For Every Special Occasion
For over 40 years, J&S Watkins Desserts has been serving the finest pies, cheesecakes, cakes, and tortes to the Clifton Park area community. Each dessert is made using the highest quality ingredients and mixed in small batches (the old-fashioned way) to ensure they offer the best flavors and appearance.
The bakery specializes in key lime pie, Toll House pie, and apple crisp pie, and they accept pre-orders before Thanksgiving and Christmas.
Visit their website or give them a call for more information about holiday orders and availability.
The holidays will be here before you know it! Plan ahead and order your family's pie in Saratoga County today.
Shop for top holiday gifts in the Saratoga area »
« Back to the Saratoga Holiday Guide
