2026 Saratoga.com Fab Five Winners: Best Pizza
Pizza lovers cast their votes for the 2026 Saratoga.com Fab Five winners for Best Pizza, highlighting top spots across the Saratoga Springs area. This category recognizes pizzerias known for signature crusts, fresh toppings, and expertly crafted slices. Track down your next go-to spot for the perfect pie.
1. Caputo's Pizzeria
Tucked into the Home Depot Plaza right on Route 50, this neighborhood stronghold has been a go-to for traditional, no-nonsense Italian comfort. Families and locals flock here for its classic New York-style thin crusts, signature Grandma pies, and a massive menu of familiar counter favorites like garlic knots, calzones, and hearty chicken parm heroes.
2. Pizza Etc.
Operating on Geyser Road just across the Ballston Spa town line, this family-owned staple has built a fierce, multi-decade following since opening in 1986. Famed for its generous toppings and signature sauce, it's the ultimate neighborhood pit stop for massive party sheets, creative specialty pies, and loaded hot subs.
3. West Avenue Pizzeria
Situated on the west side of town at 99 West Avenue, this sleek, bustling storefront delivers perfectly executed New York-style pies with a satisfyingly crisp crust. Pizza lovers praise the shop for its exceptional consistency, lightning-fast counter slice service, and an expanded menu featuring top-tier buffalo wings and loaded chicken tenders.
4. Mama Mia’s
Mama Mia’s combines hearty Italian comfort food with pizzas that remain popular among both locals and visitors. The restaurant’s welcoming setting and traditional recipes contribute to its strong reputation in the community.
5. Artisanal Brew Works
Anchored on Maple Avenue just north of the downtown strip, this sprawling craft brewery proves that pizza pairs best with locally brewed beer. Beer enthusiasts and families can settle into the high-ceilinged taproom to share artisan pies right alongside a rotating draft list of fresh IPAs.
<< Back to 2026 Fab Five Winners
