Home / Fab Five Awards / 2026 Fab Five Winners / Best Italian Food

2026 Saratoga.com Fab Five Winners: Best Italian Food

By Joe Legault

The 2026 Saratoga.com Fab Five winners for Best Italian Food showcase standout dining across the Saratoga region. This category celebrates restaurants serving exceptional Italian cuisine, from traditional favorites to modern interpretations. Plan your next meal around these spots known for rich flavors and timeless appeal.

Caputo's Pizzeria

1. Panza's Restaurant

Panza's Restaurant honors over 80 years of authentic, upscale Italian heritage from its elegant home base on South Broadway. Discerning diners settle into the intimate dining room or the vibrant live-piano lounge to savor time-tested family recipes, featuring house-made fettuccine bolognese, hand-rolled meatballs, and milk-fed veal chops paired with classic craft cocktails.

2. Mama Mia’s Restaurant

Massive, family-style comfort portions of hand-stretched brick-oven pizzas, classic spaghetti and meatballs, and towering chicken parmigiana drive the menu at this high-energy landmark. Located in the shopping plaza at 185 Ballston Avenue, its bustling atmosphere easily absorbs the noise of large, multi-generational tables out for a celebratory meal.

3. Augie's Family Style Italian Restaurant

Augie's Family Style Italian Restaurant brings the boisterous, scratch-made culinary traditions of the Bronx straight to the Saratoga region. Whether ordering from their bustling flagship dining room on Low Street in Ballston Spa or grabbing a massive feast from their Lake Avenue "To-Go" hub, crowds line up for towering platters of penne alla vodka, chicken cutlet parmigiana, and their famous "kitchen sink" pasta.

4. Solevo Kitchen

Old-school supper club energy meets sleek, modern craftsmanship at this stunning culinary hotspot located at 55 Phila Street. Run by a multi-generational restaurant family, the kitchen wows foodies with authentic scratch-made classics like Grandma Mary's all-beef meatballs slow-cooked in Sunday sauce, fried eggplant chips with chili honey, and fresh, hand-rolled pappardelle bolognese.

5. Caputo's Pizzeria

Caputo's Pizzeria combines traditional Italian comfort with a relaxed, counter-service atmosphere inside the Home Depot Plaza off Route 50. It reigns as a premier neighborhood go-to for quick weeknight dinners and casual family gatherings, serving up exceptional thin-crust New York slices, signature Grandma pies, and loaded calzones.

<< Back to 2026 Fab Five Winners

About the Author: Joe Legault Joe is a dedicated editor from Lake Luzerne, NY, with a passion for hiking the Adirondack high peaks, running half marathons and 5Ks, and visiting local craft breweries like Common Roots and Dancing Grain. He enjoys writing about the region's can't-miss attractions and activities.

Did we miss one? Did one of these places close? Send us a note!